Pros and Cons: Matt Garza

Pros and Cons: Matt Garza
November 12, 2013, 11:00 am
Share This Post

PRO: Matt Garza is a Fresno native and the idea of pitching for the Giants appeals to him. CON: A hometown discount might only go so far, as he will have many suitors. (AP)

Programming note: Get up to date on all the latest offseason Giants news on the Hot Stove Show, Tuesday night at 6:30 p.m. on Comcast SportsNet Bay Area

Editor's note: Stay logged on this offseason as Giants Insider Andrew Baggarly files his thoughts on available MLB free agents and the possibilty they could become Giants

Pros and Cons: Masahiro Tanaka
Pros and Cons: Brian McCann 
Pros and Cons: Jacoby Ellsbury 

SAN FRANCISCO – Our offseason “pros and cons” series continues with a look at perhaps the best stuff guy among free-agent starting pitchers, right-hander Matt Garza.

Should the Giants target Garza? Let’s weigh the pros and cons:

Although he had a 4.38 ERA in 13 starts following a trade from the Cubs to the Rangers, there’s a lot to like about Garza on the mound. He averaged nearly eight strikeouts per nine innings and had a 3-to-1 strikeout-to-walk ratio. He’s always a threat to throw a no-hitter. In terms of raw stuff, he stands out among a free-agent crop of starters that has decent depth but few high-ceiling arms.

Garza missed most of the second half in 2012 with a stress reaction in his elbow and he pulled a muscle in his side that kept him out of the rotation for a few weeks this past season. His medicals reportedly check out, but Garza hasn’t thrown 200 innings in a season since 2010 (he hit 198 in 2011, though) and he isn’t the best bet for a Giants rotation that needs bankable innings.

[RELATED: Matt Garza career stats | 2013 game logs]

Garza won’t require a compensatory draft pick. By rule, the Rangers couldn’t extend him a qualifying offer because they traded for him midseason. Also, Garza is a Fresno native and the idea of pitching for the Giants appeals to him.

A hometown discount might only go so far. Garza will have many suitors, and he’ll get at least a four-year deal if not five. That won’t be a great fit for the Giants, who would prefer a shorter term to bridge the gap while they develop several intriguing arms in the low minors.

Garza is a fiery competitor who certainly wouldn’t become complacent if he signed a long-term deal.

Garza can’t always control that fire, turning into a mini Carlos Zambrano on a few occasions – notably when he entered into a Twitter spat with Eric Sogard of the A’s (and Sogard’s wife, Kaycee) last season. The takeaway: some people just need to stay off Twitter.

The Giants already have a load committed to Matt Cain and now Tim Lincecum, as well as Buster Posey. Signing another pitcher to a Zito-type contract would severely restrict their flexibility to make other moves – especially if said pitcher ends up doing them no good on the disabled list. Pass.

Garza holds out for a fifth year and gets it from the Angels (along with $80 million of Arte Moreno’s money).


More Team Talk