Down stopping -- one of the heroes but to Mike I think the other that we got a point out is the bullpen. Other than Wilson give it up a couple of runs in the at the bullpen kept the Giants right where they needed to be. You want to -- that this is a great game were pretty bad stuff. Pitching all the way through the starters didn't pull this straight the Padres as the -- -- straight to the Giants. Is up and down their their their their pitching staff that they've been as -- as word that I think it's you know it's it's kind of a challenge when you think you play. It pitched against the best hope that the division possibly the league you wanna match about it wouldn't the Everett that but it always seems to get that little trouble we get I think. Fortunately the Giants gave rivals in the three run cushion the only these. The one run to a 22 whip by facility you know Giants baseball. Right -- it is and by the way don't ever. Think for 12 there isn't magic. From -- Kirk reader pulled out the stops that I. You put out the Kirk greater patch his picture was of the guys that -- guess what it's -- Arizona and he's laughing.