Gutierrez: Tom Cable's confusing QB carousel

277065.jpg

Gutierrez: Tom Cable's confusing QB carousel

Nov. 29, 2010
GUTIERREZ ARCHIVE
RAIDERS PAGE RAIDERS VIDEO

Paul Gutierrez
CSNCalifornia.com

"It's clear cut. There's no issue there in my mind. What we've done (are) some nice things in the last two weeks. You've got to take your hat off to Jason, nice job on his part, as well as the rest of the offensive players. But we know who our quarterback is." Raiders' coach Tom Cable on Nov. 1, insisting that the then-injured Bruce Gradkowski was Oakland's starting quarterback over Jason Campbell, despite Campbell having led the Raiders to consecutive blowout wins over Denver and Seattle by a combined 92-17.

OAKLAND -- Tom Cable was an unknown commodity when Al Davis tabbed him to replace Lane Kiffin after four games of the 2008 season. Not even the Raiders owner was completely sure to whom he was handing the reins over, what with Davis' private comments about him during that epic overhead projector media conference played in an oh-so public setting.

"Who's going to introduce Tom Cable?" Davis asked an assistant at the time. "I don't know that much about him. Get something. Get his press guide."

Cable was short on head coaching experience, but he more than made up for it with his player-friendly mien, the way the offensive line guru related to the grunts.

He was overmatched last season as a play-caller, who can ever forget that doomed-from-the-start fake field goal that called for Sebastian Janikowski to run 18 yards for a first down but resulted in a 67-yard touchdown for Kansas City in an eventual 20-13 defeat? Yet he accomplished something even more noteworthy. He changed the defeatist culture in the Raiders locker room.

All-Pro punter Shane Lechler even credited the rough-around-edges Cable, who survived charges of breaking assistant Randy Hanson's jaw in a training camp dustup and stories of domestic violence, as a beacon of belief. Lechler said there was nothing necessarily untrustworthy about Bill Callahan, Norv Turner, Art Shell or Kiffin (on second thought about that guy), it was just that they could really trust Cable.

Except, here's the thing: Cable, who espouses the dogma of staying-the-course like some politico on a bully pulpit is sounding more and more like a politician.

"I really haven't wavered. But I do have a belief in me (that) when you're dealing with it and you got the hot hand and things are going in the right direction for your football team, why would you make a change?" Cable on Nov. 8, explaining why he was contemplating sticking with Campbell over Gradkowski.

Catch my drift?

Cable is walking a fine line. He is in danger of losing credibility and dividing a once-firmly united locker room with his flip-flopping at quarterback. What once was a mild curiosity has become needless drama.

Cable's silly game of cloak and dagger with not only the media, but the fans and the players themselves was a complete flop courtesy of the Raiders' 33-17 meltdown against an uninspiring Miami Dolphins team.

"(The) quarterback will be Jason. He will start at quarterback. He's earned the right to do that. Four out of the last five games are wins. And Bruce will back him up and we'll move forward from there." Cable on Nov. 15, re-affirming his decision to stick with Campbell, who had led the Raiders to their first three-game winning streak in eight years.

Applying logic while roaming the streets of Silver and Blackdom is always a tricky proposition. But we know this: Campbell is Davis' guy. Acquired him in a draft weekend trade, gave him an additional year on his contract and compared him to Jim Plunkett during camp. Gradkowski, meanwhile, is Cable's guy. Saved his skin last season in Pittsburgh. Did it again in this season's home opener against St. Louis.

Against the Dolphins, though? Not so much. This might serve as Cable's Waterloo.

"He'll be the starter next week. There is no issue there." Cable on Nov. 21, following the 35-3 loss at Pittsburgh and saying again, Campbell was his starter.

So what happened?

Against the Dolphins, it really didn't matter if the Raiders had Plunkett under center. Or Ken Stabler. Not when the running game could only muster 16 yards on the ground. Or when the defense could not get off the field and allowed 471 total yards, 186 rushing.

"Nothing else matters, muttered offensive tackle Khalif Barnes. "You've got to be able to move the rock in the trenches."

"You also have to have some semblance of continuity. Because while teammates have long claimed that it does not matter who is quarterback, it does. Especially with such strikingly divergent skill sets as those owned by the helter-skelterish Gradkowski and the more classically-trained Campbell."

"I didn't understand the whole thing," Campbell said after the game. "(Cable) explained to me that when Bruce is healthy, fully healthy, he goes back in as the starter. My thing was, in the Pittsburgh game (last week), I was like, well, he was healthy."

"And yet, Campbell started against the Steelers, was pummeled and replaced in the third quarter. So starts anew the talk that Campbell is caught in the middle of a familiar tug of war between coach and owner."

"It's not easy," Campbell said. "It's not an easy thing to be going through, by no means. You're a competitor, you like to compete, but by no means are you understanding or anything."

"It's kind of tough because you're caught right in between something and you don't know what's going on, don't really understand the situation. I'm just caught in between a tough place. You don't know which direction?"

Campbell caught himself and stopped himself from saying anything further. But it was obvious he was lost in the latest dysfunction.

"Gradkowski, meanwhile, was anything but the spark the Raiders needed in his first start since Oct. 10, when he suffered a separated shoulder against the Chargers. He threw for 252 yards on 17 of 32 passing with a touchdown and two interceptions. "

Were it not for the heroics of rookie receiver Jacoby Ford, Gradkowski's 63.5 passer rating would have been significantly more unsightly.

"I mean, it's tough," Gradkowski said when asked if he feared a divided locker room over the QB Carousel.

"But I think we're handling it well as a team. I think, especially in the QB room, we're all together. Throughout the game, Jason's talking to me. We just talk through things. And I think whatever decision coach makes, we just go with it."

"The players are going to respect whosever out there, and they're going to play hard no matter what."

We'll see.

"I've said all along when Bruce was 100 percent and ready to go and could do everything we needed to do, he'd be the starter. That was the reason for it." Cable following the loss to the Dolphins, explaining why Gradkowski started.

"And at that time he was. Then on Wednesday when we started practice they confirmed to me he was 100 percent healthy." Cable, when reminded he said the previous Sunday that Campbell was the starter.

The Raiders QB Carousel may have finally spun to a stop, though. Gradkowski injured his shoulder again on Oakland's final offensive play, a broken play that resulted in an incomplete shovel pass.

So, what have we learned? Well, from here on out, Campbell appears to be the starter. Until he's not.

What's your take? Email Paul and let him know. He may use it in his Mailbag.

Inactives: Raiders LG Kelechi Osemele a late scratch due to illness

osemele-white-raiders.jpg
USATSI

Inactives: Raiders LG Kelechi Osemele a late scratch due to illness

KANSAS CITY, Mo. – Raiders left guard Kelechi Osemele was questionable to play Thursday night’s game at Kansas City with a knee sprain.

His knee is doing just fine, thank you.

Even still, Osemele wasn’t ready to play. He was a late scratch due to an illness, which sapped him to the point he couldn’t go.

Osemele was listed about the Raiders inactives, announced shortly before kickoff.

That creates a huge void in the offensive line – the Raiders run best between Osemele and left tackle Donald Penn – that will be filled by rookie Vadal Alexander.

Alexander is an aggressive player and a good run blocker, but he isn’t on Osemele’s level. Not having the high-priced player could hinder the Raiders offensive line, which must remain strong for the attack to operate well. The Raiders have allowed a league-low 13 sacks this season. 

Defensive tackle Darius Latham was questionable with an ankle injury, but wasn’t quite ready to play this game. This marks his second contest missed with injury.

Strong safety Karl Joseph was ruled out earlier in the week with a toe injury. Cornerback Antonio Hamilton, Shilique Calhoun, Connor Cook and Stacy McGee are also inactive.

Raiders 'don't mind tough things,' ready for adverse conditions vs Chiefs

Raiders 'don't mind tough things,' ready for adverse conditions vs Chiefs

KANSAS CITY, Mo. – Arrowhead Stadium has literally become a frozen tundra. Heaters under the playing surface malfunctioned on Wednesday night, allowing a layer of ice to form under the tarp in below freezing temperatures.

That information comes courtesy of an NFL Network reporter on site Thursday morning in advance of an evening showdown between the rival Raiders and Chiefs.

The field is expected to thaw by kickoff, but any remaining ice patch would add to the adversity facing the Silver and Black in a pivotal AFC West showdown.

They are the only NFL team to travel more than one time zone to play on “Thursday Night Football,” adding another wrinkle to a game that deserves to be played on regular rest. Instead teams will square off in a made-for-TV event without much time to prepare

Raiders head coach Jack Del Rio could’ve griped about an adverse lot, but he refused to line up reasons why his team might not play well.

“We’re going to be excited to play,” Del Rio said. “It’s a tough set of circumstances. We don’t mind tough things. We’re looking forward to the challenge.”

Beating the Chiefs is a daunting task. The Raiders weren’t up to it earlier this year, when Kansas City came to Oakland and made it their home. The Raiders must even the score or find themselves in a bind. Kansas City would own the divisional tiebreaker with three games remaining, and would be in great position to win the AFC West.

The Chiefs have been Raiders kryptonite in recent seasons. They have won six of seven matchups, a trend the Raiders hope to buck on Thursday night.

“Everyone mentions, ‘They’ve beaten you this many times,’ and these things and all of that,” Raiders quarterback Derek Carr said. “When I’m preparing for these guys, it never goes through my head. That stuff never has a determining factor on anything I write down, anything that goes on in my brain or anything like that. I just prepare for them just like I do any other game. I prepare for them the same way that I do for everybody. I’m going to go out there, and I’m looking forward to competing against them though this time.”

Carr won’t compete from under center. The Raiders will stay in shotgun and pistol formations for a second straight week to protect a right pinky finger dislocated in two places against the Carolina Panthers. That shouldn’t limit them much, though it makes life harder on the run game.

The Raiders performed pretty well on the ground against Buffalo, totaling 139 yards on 32 carries. Latavius Murray led that effort, with 82 yards and two touchdowns on 20 carries.

Murray missed the last game against Kansas City with turf toe, but will be ready to take a heavy load this time around. He has been taking more carries over the last month, with a previously equal running back rotation now shading his way. Murray should be a play a big role in this contest, which should come down to the fourth quarter.

“The Chiefs are a rival that we’ve struggled with,” Murray said. “We know what’s at stake for this season. They stand in the way of our goal of winning the division. We need to take care of them.”

The Raiders must take care of Kansas City on a short week, in loud, hostile environment. Oh, and in the bitter cold. It’s expected to be 20 degrees at kickoff, with wind coursing through Arrowhead Stadium.

The Raiders don’t mind that either. They’re 6-0 in games away from Oakland Coliseum, and are confident they can overcome adversity this particular game presents.

“You just have to get your mind right and go play,” Del Rio said. “We’ll be ready to go. We have a good group of guys. Feel like we’re weather proof. We’ll go play.”